Home / Contractor vs Employee

Contractor vs Employee

Compare all-in cost of 1099 vs W-2.

Details

Results

Cheaper option
Employee all-in cost
Contractor total
Difference

Estimate only. Tax rates and benefit costs vary by state and employer.

How it works

We build the employee's all-in cost (salary + payroll taxes + benefits + overhead) and compare it to the contractor's rate times annual hours.

Contractors win for variable work; employees win for steady full-time roles.

CostToHireGuide has more free tools

Price your team with our free hiring-cost tools.

Higher rate, lower total — sometimes

A contractor’s hourly rate looks expensive next to a salary, but you skip payroll taxes, benefits, PTO and most overhead — and you only pay for hours worked. For part-time, project, or variable needs, a contractor often costs less overall. For full-time, ongoing work, an employee usually wins once you spread their fixed costs across a full year.

Cost isn’t the only factor

Beyond dollars, weigh control, availability, IP ownership and the legal risk of misclassification — the IRS and states care a lot about whether a "contractor" is really an employee. Use this for the money comparison, then factor in the rest.

Good to know

FAQs

Is a contractor cheaper than an employee?

Often for part-time or project work; employees usually win for full-time ongoing roles.

What costs do contractors avoid?

Payroll taxes, benefits, PTO and most overhead.

What about misclassification?

The IRS/states penalize treating real employees as contractors — get it right.

Is this legal advice?

No — it's a cost estimate.